FANDOM


Alternate Returning Castaways are past contestants who were considered to return for a subsequent season, but either were not chosen or declined the offer.

Alternate casting is a subject of much rumor and speculation, so this list includes contestants with a reliable source' (such as production or contestant interviews) to support their alleged involvement in the casting process. However, these are only claims to involvement in the casting process, and may not accurately reflect what actually happened behind the casting doors.

Survivor: All-StarsEdit

Contestant Status Additional Notes
AVGN colored Angry Video Game Nerd
Reals vs. OCs
Declined Angry Video Game Nerd was still bitter over his loss in Reals vs. OCs, that he declined the offer to return to the game. He later returned in Survivor: Heroes vs. Villains and Survivor: Edenia.
Banjo colored Banjo
SEGA All Stars
Declined Banjo declined the offer to appear on the season, having no interest to play again. Despite this, he later returned in Survivor: Redemption Island.
Ben colored Ben
Green Hill
Declined Ben was visiting his family in Singapore, and was forced to decline the offer. He later returned in Survivor: Fans vs. Favorites and Survivor: Heroes vs. Villains.
Eric colored Eric
Green Hill
Claimed Eric claimed that he was originally cast to appear on All-Stars, but was replaced with one of Kevin or Sabastian.
Jacky colored Jacky
SEGA All Stars
Declined Jacky was offered the chance to return to finish what he started, but he wasn't interested in playing again, and declined. Despite this, he later returned in Survivor: Fans vs. Favorites and Survivor: Heroes vs. Villains.
Jada colored Jada
Reals vs. OCs
Declined/Cut Producers wanted both Jada and her boyfriend Quinn to appear on the season. However, both of them didn't want to play together again, and Quinn was chosen over Jada. She later returned for Survivor: Fans vs. Favorites.
Jess colored Jess
Green Hill
Declined Jess declined the offer to return to the game, only seeing a need to play once, and then never again.
Ryan colored Ryan
Emerald Hill
Declined Ryan declined the offer to return to play the game again, having been wrapped up in baseball season.

Survivor: Fans vs. FavoritesEdit

Before this season became Fans vs. Favorites, it was originally Fans vs. Second Chances, with 13 pre merge boots being considered for the season. The format was changed, however, due to popular demand.

Contestant Status Additional Notes
BD Joe colored B.D. Joe
SEGA All Stars
Considered B.D. Joe was one of the players considered for Survivor: Fans vs. Second Chances, but due to the format change, he was left out. He later returned for Survivor: Destiny Isles.
Billy colored Billy
SEGA All Stars
Cut Billy went through casting process to be a Favorite on this season, but was replaced by alliance buddy Amigo.
Cloud colored Cloud
Reals vs. OCs
Considered Cloud was one of the players considered for Survivor: Fans vs. Second Chances, but due to the format change, he was left out. He later returned for Survivor: Destiny Isles.
Galaxo colored Galaxo
Koopa Beach
Considered Galaxo was one of the players considered for Survivor: Fans vs. Second Chances, but due to the format change, he was left out. He later returned for Survivor: Unfinished Business.
Jared colored Jared
Emerald Hill
Considered Jared was one of the players considered for Survivor: Fans vs. Second Chances, but due to the format change, he was left out. He later returned for Survivor: Destiny Isles.
Kory colored Kory
Emerald Hill
Considered Kory was one of the players considered for Survivor: Fans vs. Second Chances, but due to the format change, he was left out.
Leafeon colored Leafeon
Cuties
Considered Leafeon was one of the players considered for Survivor: Fans vs. Second Chances, but due to the format change, she was left out. She later returned for Survivor: Destiny Isles.
Luigi colored Luigi
Reals vs. OCs
Considered Luigi was one of the players considered for Survivor: Fans vs. Second Chances, but due to the format change, he was left out. He later returned for Survivor: Destiny Isles and Survivor: Blood vs. Water.
Marcus colored Marcus
Green Hill
Considered Marcus was one of the players considered for Survivor: Fans vs. Second Chances, but due to the format change, he was left out.
Rob colored Rob
Reals vs. OCs
Considered Rob was one of the players considered for Survivor: Fans vs. Second Chances, but due to the format change, he was left out.
Robert colored Robert
Marble
Cut Robert was offered and later accepted the chance to return back to the game right after winning the game. But producers later dropped him for being a winner, wanting to save him for another season. He later returned for Survivor: Heroes vs. Villains.
Sagwa colored Sagwa
Cuties
Considered Sagwa was one of the players considered for Survivor: Fans vs. Second Chances, but due to the format change, she was left out.
Scott colored Scott
Emerald Hill
Considered Scott was one of the players considered for Survivor: Fans vs. Second Chances, but due to the format change, he was left out.
Shadow colored Shadow
SEGA All Stars
Considered Shadow was one of the players considered for Survivor: Fans vs. Second Chances, but due to the format change, he was left out. He later returned for Survivor: Destiny Isles.
Vixey colored Vixey
Cuties
Considered Vixey was one of the players considered for Survivor: Fans vs. Second Chances, but due to the format change, she was left out. She later returned for Survivor: Destiny Isles.

Survivor: Heroes vs. VillainsEdit

Contestant Status Additional Notes
Cyrano2 colored Cyrano
Distant
Cut Cyrano was planned to be on this season, but due to low ratings on Distant, he was cut. Had he made the cut, he would've been a hero.
Gonzo2 colored Gonzo
Distant
Declined/Cut Gonzo was offered the chance to return to the game, but he turned the offer down. It was later reported that Gonzo would've been cut anyway, due to Distant's low ratings. Gonzo would've been a villain, had he made it.
Heath colored Heath
Emerald Hill
Cut Heath was casted and made the final processes for playing the game again. However, he was cut in favor of having more well known villains.
Junior colored Junior
Green Hill
SEGA All Stars
All-Stars
Declined Junior was offered the chance to return to Survivor for a fourth time, but he declined due to moving back to his home country, and starting a family with his wife. He would've been a hero, had he accepted it.
Mark colored Mark
Emerald Hill
Declined Mark turned the offer down to appear as a hero, with real no explanation why he chose to do so.
Midna colored Midna
Cuties
Cut Midna accepted the offer to appear as a villain, but was cut with no real explanation why. She latered returned to Survivor: Prison Island.
Roy colored Roy
Koopa Beach
Cut Roy was casted and made the final processes for playing the game again. However, he was cut in favor of having more well known heroes.

Survivor: Aquatic RuinEdit

While not technically returning players, these four Mass Effect alumni applied and were casted on Aquatic Ruin, but were replaced with OCs.

Contestant Status Additional Notes
Garrus colored Garrus Cut Garrus applied for this season, but was replaced; along with many others, with OCs. He was later seen on Survivor: Virmire.
Jack colored Jack Cut Jack applied for this season, but was replaced; along with many others, with OCs. She was later seen on Survivor: Forest Maze.
Mordin colored Mordin Cut Mordin applied for this season, but was replaced; along with many others, with OCs. He was later seen on Survivor: Virmire.
Zaeed colored Zaeed Cut Zaeed applied for this season, but was replaced; along with many others, with OCs. He was later seen on Survivor: Forest Maze.

Survivor: VirmireEdit

Contestant Status Additional Notes
AVGN colored Angry Video Game Nerd
Reals vs. OCs
Heroes vs. Villains
Considered Angry Video Game Nerd was in consideration to bring back for this season, along with fellow villains Limberg and Sweet Tooth, but producers decided to bring back pre merge boots, believing the villains didn't stand a chance. He would later appear in Survivor: Edenia.
Dexter colored Dexter
Aquatic Ruin
Declined Dexter was considered to be the Aquatic Ruin candidate for the returnee. However, he declined the offer, as he was busy with his 'serial killer business'. He would later appear in Survivor: Destiny Isles and Survivor: Battle Royale.
Limberg2 colored Limberg
Distant
Heroes vs. Villains
Considered Limberg was in consideration to bring back for this season, along with fellow villains Angry Video Game Nerd and Sweet Tooth, but producers decided to bring back pre merge boots, believing the villains didn't stand a chance. He would later appear in Survivor: Edenia.
Skarloey colored Skarloey Offered Skarloey, according to Duncan, was offered a spot to appear on the season, likely in his place in case he declined. He would later appear in Survivor: Beach Bowl Galaxy.
Sweet Tooth colored Sweet Tooth
Aquatic Ruin
Considered Sweet Tooth was in consideration to bring back for this season, along with fellow villains Angry Video Game Nerd and Limberg, but producers decided to bring back pre merge boots, believing the villains didn't stand a chance. He would later appear in Survivor: Ultimates.

Survivor: UltimatesEdit

Contestant Status Additional Notes
Andrew colored Andrew
Emerald Hill
All-Stars
Heroes vs. Villains
Cut Andrew was originally casted to be on this season, but due to the format change, he was cut from the group.
AVGN colored Angry Video Game Nerd
Reals vs. OCs
Heroes vs. Villains
Cut Angry Video Game Nerd was originally casted to be on this season, but due to the format change, he was cut from the group. He would later appear on Survivor: Edenia.
Banjo colored Banjo
SEGA All Stars
Redemption Island
Cut Banjo was originally casted to be on this season, but due to the format change, he was cut from the group.
Beat colored Beat
SEGA All Stars
All-Stars
Heroes vs. Villains
Cut Beat was originally casted to be on this season, but due to the format change, he was cut from the group.
Ben colored Ben
Green Hill
Fans vs. Favorites
Heroes vs. Villains
Cut Ben was originally casted to be on this season, but due to the format change, he was cut from the group.
Brandon colored Brandon
Aquatic Ruin
Cut Brandon went through casting process for this season, but he was cut in favor of Ling Ling.
Duck colored Duck
Forest Maze
Cut Duck went through casting process for this season, but he was cut in favor of the more popular Kasumi.
Enoch colored Enoch
Marble
Fans vs. Favorites
Cut Enoch was originally casted to be on this season, but due to the format change, he was cut from the group.
Eric colored Eric
Green Hill
Cut Eric was originally casted to be on this season, but due to the format change, he was cut from the group.
Etna colored Etna
Cuties
Heroes vs. Villains
Cut Etna was originally casted to be on this season, but due to the format change, she was cut from the group.
Grune colored Grune
Virmire
Cut Grune went through casting process for this season, but she was cut for unknown reasons.
Kruz colored Kruz
Emerald Hill
All-Stars
Cut Kruz was originally casted to be on this season, but due to the format change, he was cut from the group.
Limberg2 colored Limberg
Distant
Heroes vs. Villains
Cut Limberg was originally casted to be on this season, but due to the format change, he was cut from the group. He would later appear on Survivor: Edenia.
Midna colored Midna
Cuties
Cut Midna was originally casted to be on this season, but due to the format change, she was cut from the group. She would later appear on Survivor: Prison Island.
No-Face colored No-Face
Redemption Island
Cut No-Face went through casting process for this season, but he was cut in favor of Ren. He would later appear on Survivor: Prison Island.
Ryo colored Ryo
SEGA All Stars
All-Stars
Cut Ryo was originally casted to be on this season, but due to the format change, he was cut from the group.
Samantha colored Samantha
Koopa Beach
Cut Samantha was originally casted to be on this season, but due to the format change, she was cut from the group.
Stepney colored Stepney
Aquatic Ruin
Claimed Stepney claims he was contacted to appear on this season, but was cut. He later called the producers out on putting in Harry over him, thinking they were trying to give Sweet Tooth an advantage.
Will colored Will
Green Hill
All-Stars
Heroes vs. Villains
Cut Will was originally casted to be on this season, but due to the format change, he was cut from the group. He would later appear on Survivor: Blood vs. Water.

Survivor: EdeniaEdit

While not technically a returning player, this player was considered for Edenia, but was replaced.

Contestant Status Additional Notes
Scorpion2 colored Scorpion Cut Scorpion was originally recruited to be on Survivor: Edenia, but producers felt that Noob Saibot had a bigger background compared to Scorpion, so he was replaced. He was later seen on Survivor: Prison Island.

Survivor: Destiny IslesEdit

Contestant Status Additional Notes
Evan colored Evan
Green Hill
Declined Evan was casted and agreed to go onto Destiny Isles, but due to his newborn baby being born the night before he left, he decided to leave, and not participate last minute.
Garrus colored Garrus
Virmire
Declined Garrus was offered a spot on Destiny Isles, but was currently busy fighting against the Reapers in his world, and couldn't make the time to return at the time. He would later appear on Survivor: Unfinished Business.
Javik colored Javik
Virmire
Considered Javik was a consideration for a replacement for Evan after he dropped out. But Javik was dropped in favor of Hartman. He would later be seen on Survivor: Unfinished Business.
Scott colored Scott
Emerald Hill
Cut Scott was set to compete on Destiny Isles, but was cut at the last minute in favor of Urcle.

Survivor: Prison IslandEdit

Contestant Status Additional Notes
Etna colored Etna
Cuties
Heroes vs. Villains
Considered Etna was included on the poll for returning players. She had very few votes to return, which ruled her out of the contest.
Grune colored Grune
Virmire
Considered Grune was included on the poll for returning players. She had very few votes to return, which ruled her out of the contest.
Heath colored Heath
Emerald Hill
Considered Heath was included on the poll for returning players. He had very few votes to return, which ruled him out of the contest.
Jess colored Jess
Green Hill
Considered Jess was included on the poll for returning players. She had a lot of votes to return, but she came just short of beating Midna.
Moses colored Moses
Virmire
Ultimates
Considered Moses was included on the poll for returning players. He had several votes to return, but not enough to bring him back.
Presea colored Presea
Forest Maze
Considered Presea was included on the poll for returning players. She had several votes to return, but not enough to bring her back.
Rachel colored Rachel
Koopa Beach
Considered Rachel was included on the poll for returning players. She had several votes to return, but not enough to bring her back.
Roy colored Roy
Koopa Beach
Considered Roy was included on the poll for returning players. He had several votes to return, but not enough to bring him back.
Shohn colored Shohn
Marble
Heroes vs. Villains
Considered Shohn was included on the poll for returning players. He had a lot of votes to return, but he came just short of beating Knuckles.
Sindel colored Sindel
Edenia
Considered Sindel was included on the poll for returning players. She had a lot of votes to return, but she came just short of beating Kasumi. She would later appear on Survivor: Blood vs. Water and Survivor: Battle Royale.
Stepney colored Stepney
Aquatic Ruin
Considered Stepney was included on the poll for returning players. He had very few votes to return, which ruled him out of the contest.
Sub-Zero colored Sub-Zero
Edenia
Considered Sub-Zero was included on the poll for returning players. He had a lot of votes to return, but he came just short of beating No-Face. He would later appear on Survivor: Battle Royale.
Sunil colored Sunil Cut Sunil was originally cast for this season as one of the normal players. He was however cut in favor of including other players. He would appear instead as Pepper's loved one later in the season, and then as her boyfriend in Survivor: Blood vs. Water, where he was a contestant.
Waluigi colored Waluigi Cut Waluigi was originally cast for this season in it's alpha stages, but was cut for unknown reasons. He later appeared in Survivor: Lake Hylia.
Wave colored Wave Cut Wave was originally cast for this season in it's alpha stages, but was cut for unknown reasons. She later appeared in Survivor: Kattlelox Island.

Survivor: Blood vs. WaterEdit

Contestant Status Additional Notes
Applejack colored Applejack
Forest Maze
Considered Applejack was included on the poll for returning players, along with her brother, Big Macintosh. She came close to being considered, but came just short of votes. She would later appear on Survivor: Yoshi Desert.
Angela colored Angela
Marble
Considered Angela was included on the poll for returning players, along with her boyfriend, Spencer. She came close to being considered, but came just short of votes.
Arlando colored Arlando
Emerald Hill
Fans vs. Favorites
Considered Arlando was included on the poll for returning players, along with his brother, Alejandro. He didn't get many votes to return, thus ruling him out.
Billy colored Billy
SEGA All Stars
Considered Billy was included on the poll for returning players, along with his sister, Rolly. He was close to the top percentage of votes, but not close enough.
Chris colored Chris
Aquatic Ruin
Considered Chris was included on the poll for returning players, along with his boyfriend, Nathan. He barely got a single vote to return, so he was pretty much not eligible to return.
Cloud colored Cloud
Reals vs. OCs
Destiny Isles
Considered Cloud was included on the poll for returning players, along with his girlfriend, Tifa. He barely got a single vote to return, so he was pretty much not eligible to return.
Freddi colored Freddi
Cuties
Fans vs. Favorites
Considered Freddi was included on the poll for returning players, along with her boyfriend, Luther. She didn't get many votes to return, thus ruling her out.
Haruhi colored Haruhi
Seireitei Forest
Xing
Packers
Considered Haruhi was included on the poll for returning players, along with her boyfriend, Kyon. She came close to being considered, but came just short of votes.
Knuckles colored Knuckles
SEGA All Stars
Prison Island
Considered Knuckles was included on the poll for returning players, along with his girlfriend, Julie-Su. He was close to the top percentage of votes, but not close enough.
Kratos colored Kratos
Redemption Island
Ultimates
Considered Kratos was included on the poll for returning players, along with his son, Lloyd. He didn't get many votes to return, thus ruling him out.
Niko colored Niko
Redemption Island
Virmire
Destiny Isles
Considered Niko was included on the poll for returning players, along with his cousin, Roman. He was close to the top percentage of votes, but not close enough.
Prussia colored Prussia
Axis vs. Allies
Packers
Considered Prussia was included on the poll for returning players, along with his brother, Germany. He came close to being considered, but came just short of votes.
Samara colored Samara
Forest Maze
Destiny Isles
Considered Samara was included on the poll for returning players, along with her daughter, Falere. She didn't get many votes to return, thus ruling her out.
Senel colored Senel
Virmire
Ultimates
Considered Senel was included on the poll for returning players, along with his sister, Shirley. He barely got a single vote to return, so he was pretty much not eligible to return.
Sheeva colored Sheeva
Edenia
Considered Sheeva was included on the poll for returning players, along with her cousin, Goro. She was close to the top percentage of votes, but not close enough.
Shohn colored Shohn
Marble
Heroes vs. Villains
Considered Shohn was included on the poll for returning players, along with his step father, Fadhili. He barely got a single vote to return, so he was pretty much not eligible to return.
Sprocket2 colored Sprocket
Distant
Considered Sprocket was included on the poll for returning players, along with his girlfriend, Gladys. He barely got a single vote to return, so he was pretty much not eligible to return.
Stephen colored Stephen
Aquatic Ruin
Ultimates
Considered Stephen was included on the poll for returning players, along with his sister, Anny. He was close to the top percentage of votes, but not close enough.
Tangy2 colored Tangy
Distant
Considered Tangy was included on the poll for returning players, along with her sister, Tabby. She didn't get many votes to return, thus ruling her out.
Zing colored Zing
Koopa Beach
Considered Zing was included on the poll for returning players, along with his brother, Zoom. He came close to being considered, but came just short of votes.

Survivor: Kattlelox IslandEdit

Contestant Status Additional Notes
Mario colored Mario
Keelhaul Key
SEGA All Stars
Considered Mario was strongly considered to return to the season as a representative for Nintendo. However, craving new players, he was never asked. He was replaced with Rosalina.
Sonic colored Sonic
SEGA All Stars
All-Stars
Heroes vs. Villains
Considered Sonic was strongly considered to return to the season as a representative for Sega. However, craving new players, he was never asked. He was replaced with Wave.

Survivor: Unfinished BusinessEdit

Contestant Status Additional Notes
America colored America
Axis vs. Allies
Packers
Considered America, along with Applejack and Edward, was on the poll to return to the game, but only if he made the Top 3. He did not, and therefore did not come back, though he would later appear on Survivor: Yoshi Desert.
Applejack colored Applejack
Forest Maze
Considered Applejack, along with America and Edward, was on the poll to return to the game, but only if she made the Top 3. She did not, and therefore did not come back, though she would later appear on Survivor: Yoshi Desert.
Archer colored Archer
Aquatic Ruin
Cut Archer was on the poll to return to the game, but was not offered a spot in the game by either fans or producers.
Cloud colored Cloud
Reals vs. OCs
Destiny Isles
Cut Cloud was on the poll to return to the game, but was not offered a spot in the game by either fans or producers.
Duncan colored Duncan
Virmire
Cut Duncan was on the poll to return to the game, but was not offered a spot in the game by either fans or producers.
Edward colored Edward
Prison Island
Considered Edward, along with America and Applejack, was on the poll to return to the game, but only if he made the Top 3. He did not, and therefore did not come back.
Kazooie colored Kazooie
Cuties
Redemption Island
Cut Kazooie was on the poll to return to the game, but was not offered a spot in the game by either fans or producers.
Kenshi colored Kenshi
Edenia
Cut Kenshi was on the poll to return to the game, but was not offered a spot in the game by either fans or producers.
Leafeon colored Leafeon
Cuties
Destiny Isles
Declined Leafeon was offered a spot on the initial poll, but turned it down due to being pregnant at the time.
Minka colored Minka
Prison Island
Cut Minka was on the poll to return to the game, but was not offered a spot in the game by either fans or producers.
Presea colored Presea
Forest Maze
Cut Presea was on the poll to return to the game, but was not offered a spot in the game by either fans or producers.
Sagwa colored Sagwa
Cuties
Cut Sagwa was on the poll to return to the game, but was not offered a spot in the game by either fans or producers.
Scott colored Scott
Emerald Hill
Cut Scott was on the poll to return to the game, but was not offered a spot in the game by either fans or producers.


Survivor: Yoshi DesertEdit

Contestant Status Additional Notes
Amaterasu colored Amaterasu
Kattlelox Island
Declined According to Issun, Amaterasu declined an offer to return to the game, saying 38 days was a good finish to her. Since she was highly requested, her replacement was Rosalina.
Derpy colored Derpy
Forest Maze
Considered Derpy was close to becoming a favorite for this season, but was ultimately not picked in the end.
Gordon colored Gordon
Virmire
Considered Gordon was close to becoming a favorite for this season, but was ultimately not picked in the end.
Haruhi colored Haruhi
Seireitei Forest
Xing
Packers
Considered Haruhi was close to becoming a favorite for this season, but was ultimately not picked in the end.
Hyde colored Hyde
Singapore
Considered Hyde was close to becoming a favorite for this season, but was ultimately not picked in the end.
Ichigo colored Ichigo
Packers
Considered Ichigo was close to becoming a favorite for this season, but was ultimately not picked in the end.
Ion colored Ion
Blood vs. Water
Considered Ion was close to becoming a favorite for this season, but was ultimately not picked in the end.
Jeff the Killer colored Jeff the Killer
Prison Island
Cut Jeff the Killer was largely requested for Survivor: Yoshi Desert, however, producers felt repulsed by him, largely in due to the incident with Skarlet. Being a requested character, his replacement was Bowser.
Phoenix colored Phoenix
Kattlelox Island
Considered Phoenix was close to becoming a favorite for this season, but was ultimately not picked in the end.
Skarlet colored Skarlet
Prison Island
Considered Skarlet was close to becoming a favorite for this season, but was ultimately not picked in the end.
Sunil colored Sunil
Blood vs. Water
Considered Sunil was close to becoming a favorite for this season, but was ultimately not picked in the end. He was also the alternate for the males if a female castaway from Singapore was cast instead of Deadpool.
Trevor colored Trevor
Singapore
Considered Trevor was close to becoming a favorite for this season, but was ultimately not picked in the end. He would later appear as a coach on Survivor: Lake Hylia, where he would ultimately join the game at the merge.
Wave colored Wave
Kattlelox Island
Considered Wave was close to becoming a favorite for this season, but was ultimately not picked in the end.

Survivor: Lake HyliaEdit

While not technically a returning player, this former player was contacted to be one of three coaches for the season.

Contestant Status Additional Notes
Etna colored Etna
Cuties
Heroes vs. Villains
Considered/Declined Etna was considered and was initially offered a chance to return as a coach, but declined for unknown reasons.

Survivor: Battle RoyaleEdit

Contestant Status Additional Notes
Applejack colored Applejack
Forest Maze
Yoshi Desert
Declined Applejack was asked back, but turned the offer down, as she was pretty much done with the game after playing Yoshi Desert.
Braixen colored Braixen
Lake Hylia
Declined Braixen was asked back, but turned the offer down due to helping her now lover Greninja with her father's troubles.
Brian colored Brian
Lake Hylia
Declined Brian was asked back, but he turned the offer down due to wanting to compete against newbies as opposed to all star players, feeling it would make for an easier game.
Cynthia colored Cynthia
Shamouti Island
Packers
Blood vs. Water
Declined Cynthia was asked back, but she declined in a heartbeat, claiming that the show was rigged against her from the start, and refused to play under their rules ever again.
Deadpool colored Deadpool
Singapore
Yoshi Desert
Cut Deadpool was casted to appear on the show, but the producers decided to focus more on players gameplay, rather than comic relief, so Deadpool was cut for that very reason.
Dixie colored Dixie
Blood vs. Water
Cut Dixie was the second most requested female winner to return to the game, however, as winners were voted out of the running by the fans, Dixie was cut.
Foxy colored Foxy
Lake Hylia
Declined Foxy was asked back due to high demand, but he turned the offer down, having claimed to be a test subject for Freddy Fazbear and Bonnie before they played.
Freddy F colored Freddy Fazbear
Beach Bowl Galaxy
Considered Freddy was heavily considered to be the male returnee from his season, but production did not think Freddy would last long, given the way he played.
Greninja colored Greninja
Lake Hylia
Declined Greninja was asked back, but she declined as she was still busy with her father's troubles over in the Hoenn region.
Haruhi colored Haruhi
Seireitei Forest
Xing
Packers
Considered Haruhi was considered to being brought back, but the producers decided to not give her the call.
Jake colored Jake
Yoshi Desert
Considered Jake was close to being asked back, but was left without an offer as there were two other fans that needed a second chance more than him.
Jared colored Jared
Emerald Hill
Destiny Isles
Considered Jared was originally considered to being brought back when Deadpool was still casted. But after Deadpool was cut, Jared was also left out of consideration.
Jeff the Killer colored Jeff the Killer
Prison Island
Offered/Cut Producers were willing to give Jeff the Killer a second shot at the game after much fan demand. However, despite giving him the call, there was never an official response from Jeff. Because of that, and Skarlet agreeing to play again, he was cut.
Kitana colored Kitana
Blood vs. Water
Unfinished Business
Declined Kitana was asked back, along with her mother Sindel. However, she didn't want to compete alongside her, fearing it would make a large target on both of their backs, so she dropped out, since she already made the Final 2.
Martian Manhunter colored Martian Manhunter
Singapore
Declined Martian Manhunter was asked back, but he declined saying that he got what he wanted out of Survivor, and had no purpose to return.
Midna colored Midna
Cuties
Prison Island
Cut Midna was casted to appear on the season, but she was cut for unknown reasons.
Nightwolf colored Nightwolf
Edenia
Cut Nightwolf was the most requested male winner to return to the game, however, as winners were voted out of the running by the fans, Nightwolf was cut.
Reala colored Reala
Kattlelox Island
Cut Reala was the second most requested male winner to return to the game, however, as winners were voted out of the running by the fans, Reala was cut.
Samara colored Samara
Forest Maze
Destiny Isles
Considered Samara was originally considered to be a returning player, but producers believed she wouldn't return anyway after her code was abused by Barney in Destiny Isles.
Tatsuki colored Tatsuki
Hueco Mundo
Packers
Cut Tatsuki was the most requested female winner to return to the game, however, as winners were voted out of the running by the fans, Tatsuki was cut.

Ad blocker interference detected!


Wikia is a free-to-use site that makes money from advertising. We have a modified experience for viewers using ad blockers

Wikia is not accessible if you’ve made further modifications. Remove the custom ad blocker rule(s) and the page will load as expected.